How to Use Cheese in Your Thanksgiving Leftover Recipes

Pamela Vachon
Hands holding two sandwiches cut in half stacked on top of eachother

Give new life to your Thanksgiving leftover recipes with one simple addition: cheese.

While many of us live for Thanksgiving leftover recipes, some of us鈥攁fter a few days of turkey and stuffing on repeat 鈥 need something new on the menu. That鈥檚 where culinary creativity comes in. The answer to 鈥溾榃hat do I do with my Thanksgiving leftovers?鈥 is simple: Repurpose them!

Though this idea isn鈥檛 new, most Thanksgiving leftover ideas focus on the meal鈥檚 original components 鈥 things like turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes and cranberry sauce.

But what about the cheese? Specifically, how can you repurpose the cheeses left over from your holiday cheese plate, and how can you use cheeses that you have on hand to make leftovers recipes from the aforementioned turkey and stuffing and mashed?

Here are a few ideas for creating something new and interesting when Thanksgiving dinner fatigue sets in.

How to Use Gouda in Thanksgiving Leftovers

Gouda is a naturally sweet cheese. In an extra cheesemaking step that most cheeses don鈥檛 undergo, gouda鈥檚 curds are rinsed, washing away some of the lactose that would typically become lactic acid as cheeses age. As a result, both young and aged goudas have buttery or butterscotch notes. This distinguishes gouda from other styles of cheese, and makes it a versatile pairing for an array of diverse flavors.

Turkey, Gouda, and Butternut Squash Salad

For those craving salad (understandably, after the excesses of Thanksgiving dinner), cubed or shredded gouda makes an excellent addition to a green salad with turkey and butternut squash. Cranberry sauce can even be coaxed into a light and lively salad dressing.

A white bowl filled with salad sits on a wooden table

Gouda and Cranberry Cheese Ball

Remix your Thanksgiving leftovers into a perfect appetizer-ish snack. You can swap sweet, shredded gouda into any cheese ball recipe you like, adding cranberry sauce or fresh cranberries to the creamy mixture before rolling the ball in chopped nuts to finish.

How to Use Brie in Thanksgiving Leftovers

Brie comes from an umbrella family of what is known as bloomy rind cheese. Brie鈥檚 delicate white rind lends a slightly earthy or mushroomy taste to a profile that is otherwise mild and buttery. Brie also has a delightful ooze when warmed.

Thanksgiving Leftovers Baked Brie

Following Chef Herve Guillard鈥檚 tips for making baked Brie cheese, why not give it a post-Thanksgiving spin? Whatever size wedge or round of Brie you have on hand, split the cheese lengthwise, fill with a layer of extra stuffing and cranberry sauce, then wrap in a puff pastry and bake.

No pastry? No problem. It鈥檚 just as good unwrapped and served with baguette slices or crackers.

Baked Brie cheese on a black plate surrounded by garnishes
Chef Herve's baked Brie cheese.

Turkey Cranberry Grilled Cheese

In this unique grilled cheese sandwich recipe, Brie is a surprisingly delicious companion to turkey. It鈥檚 gooey, complex, and not so overpowering that it outshines (versus enhances) the turkey鈥檚 flavor. Cranberry provides the brightness that all thanksgiving leftover recipes need.

Read more:  Understanding Cheese Rinds

How to Use Comt茅 or Gruy猫re in Thanksgiving Leftovers

These Alpine style cheeses 鈥 Comt茅 from France and Gruy猫re from Switzerland 鈥 are excellent melting cheeses. During the cheesemaking process, their curds are gently heated to extract more liquid and, as a result, better knit the curds together. When melted, these well-knit curds made the cheese more elastic (aka stretchy). Comt茅 and Gruy猫re both have a complex, savory flavor that can give a hint of onion on the palate.

Pumpkin Fondue

If you have leftover pumpkin, either as a raw ingredient or as pumpkin pie, melt it along with an Alpine-style cheese and a splash of white wine for an inspired, Thanksgiving-style fondue that鈥檚 perfect for dunking torn pieces of dinner rolls or apple slices.

Thanksgiving Tartiflette

Tartiflette is a French casserole involving a layer of cheese over a mixture of potatoes, onions and bacon. Though typically made with a soft cheese like Reblochon, Comt茅 or Gruy猫re can stand in for an extra savory note. You can turn your entire spread of Thanksgiving leftovers into a casserole with this application, or simply melt an Alpine-style cheese over a plate of turkey or ham, mashed potatoes and pickles, raclette-style.

Read more:  Get to Know Your Alpine Cheeses

Food writer and cheese expert Pamela Vachon wearing green shirt, wavy brown hair and glasses standing against a curtained backdrop and smiling.

Pamela Vachon is a freelance food and travel writer and ICE graduate (国产福利 '11) whose work has appeared in Bon Appetit, Travel + Leisure and Wine Enthusiast, among others. She is a certified sommelier and non-certified cheese expert who teaches at NYC's Murray's Cheese.